Controversial Nativity Scene Sparks Dialogue in Dedham Church
The Archbishop of Boston, Richard Henning, is set to meet with Father Stephen Josoma of St. Susanna’s Parish in Dedham after the holidays to discuss a contentious nativity scene. This display, which has raised eyebrows since its installation shortly after Thanksgiving, features a twist on the traditional portrayal of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph, suggesting, instead, that the holy family has been apprehended by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents.
Background of the Nativity Scene
The nativity scene at St. Susanna’s Parish has garnered attention for its provocative message. In a departure from convention, the display omits the figures of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph, implying they have been detained. Father Josoma articulated the intention behind this controversial setup, stating that it aims to "create dialogue around contemporary life." Indeed, St. Susanna’s has a history of using its nativity displays to provoke discussion; in 2018, they presented a scene depicting baby Jesus in a cage.
Archdiocesan Response
Following the public outcry and divisive reactions, the Archdiocese of Boston has expressed disapproval of the display, insisting that it should be removed. In a statement, the Archdiocese asserted, "The people of God have the right to expect that, when they come to church, they will encounter genuine opportunities for prayer and Catholic worship—not divisive political messaging." This sentiment aligns with traditional church norms, which prohibit using sacred symbols for purposes other than fostering worship and devotion.
Mixed Reactions from the Community
ICE Director Todd Lyons labeled the nativity scene "abhorrent," condemning it for promoting what he calls a "dangerous and extremist narrative." The intervention from both church authorities and federal agents highlights the significant community division surrounding this nativity portrayal.
During the Christmas Day Mass at St. Susanna’s, Father Josoma made a subtle reference to the display’s notoriety. He suggested to attendees that mentioning their visit to his parish might elicit judgment from others, humorously advising them to respond with warmth, saying, "Just say, ‘it’s so good to see you!’"
Upcoming Meeting: Fostering Dialogue
Archbishop Henning has acknowledged his intention to quietly listen to Father Josoma during their upcoming conversation, scheduled for January. Henning noted, "My first thing will be just to hear him out and listen." This upcoming meeting promises to delve deeper into the motives behind the nativity scene and may serve as a turning point in addressing both community concerns and ecclesiastical protocols.
Conclusion
As the Archdiocese of Boston prepares for this important dialogue, the broader implications of using sacred displays to engage with pressing societal issues remain a topic of conversation. The controversy surrounding the nativity scene serves as a poignant reminder of the complex intersections between faith, community, and socio-political issues in contemporary society.
For further reading, see how the church has navigated similar controversies in the past or explore more about the role of nativity scenes in modern religious expressions.
